First-ever ICTR trial transfer could be recalled from Rwanda

02 June 2015 by Clive Muhenga, Arusha (Tanzania)

The UN Mechanism for International Criminal Tribunals (MICT) has for the first time said that a genocide case handed over to the Rwandan judiciary by the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) may have to be returned, due to fair trial concerns. If taken, the decision would be a serious setback for the Arusha court’s exit strategy.
 

Rwandan genocide court artwork by Surian Soosay (Photo: Flickr/ssoosay)
Image caption: 
Rwandan genocide court artwork by Surian Soosay (Photo: Flickr/ssoosay)

Jean Uwinkindi’s transfer to Rwanda was the first to be approved by the ICTR. Long under pressure from the UN to finalize all cases, the court heard its last appeals case in April [IJT-180], and has been expected to finally close its doors when that judgment is announced. Its residual functions, including monitoring transferred cases, have been absorbed by the MICT, which operates with a fraction of its predecessors’ UN-level staffing.

The ICTR transferred Uwinkindi’s case to Kigali on 19 April 2012, following a long legal battle by lawyers of the Pentecostal pastor. Previously, the ICTR had rejected all transfer requests by the prosecutor, arguing that Rwanda lacked conditions for fair trials. But after Kigali implemented a series of reforms, the court finally agreed.

Yet some observers remain unconvinced. Carina Tertsakian, a researcher on Rwanda for Human Rights Watch, tells IJT that despite important legal and administrative reforms, “we believe that the Rwandan justice system still lacks sufficient guarantees of independence, and that fair trials cannot be guaranteed in all cases”.

Want to read more?

If you subscribe to a free membership, you can read this article and explore our full archive, dating back to 1997.

Subscribe now

Related articles

article
21 December 2011 by Thijs Bouwknegt

Being the ICC's Chief Prosecutor is a delicate and politically sensitivejob.ForLuisMorenoOcampo it has been "the best job in the world." Fatou Bensouda will be taking over his office in June. She inhe

article
07 December 2011 by Thijs Bouwknegt

December 7, 2011 Ivory Coast is the latest playgroundoftheInternationalCriminal Court. This week the courtroom in The Hague became its theatre of justice. Chief Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo proudly p

article
07 December 2011 by Richard Walker

Four Congolese witnesses testifying at the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, find themselves caught in a legal wrangle, which could at once set a legal precedent and make them the last

article
07 December 2011 by Lindy Janssen

Brazil is booming. The economy is expanding and the country is getting ready to host the Football World Cup in 2014 and the Olympics in 2016. But the Latin American giant has not even begun dealing wi

article
07 December 2011 by Radosa Milutinovic

The primary purpose of the retrial of Ramush Haradinaj, as proclaimed by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in its appeal judgement in July, should have been to hear testimonies of two "key" witnesses who proved unwilling to testify in the original trial in 2007. Almost four months into the retrial which started in mid-August, its stated aim has not yet been achieved.