The Piracy Conundrum

06 September 2010 by Kenneth Manusama

On 25 August 2010, the UN Secretary-General published a report at the behest of the UN Security Council (UNSC), on the available options ‘to further the aim of prosecuting and imprisoning persons responsible for acts of piracy and armed robbery at sea off the coast of Somalia.’ This report can be seen as a summary of a debate that was started in 2009 within the confines of the Contact Group on Piracy off the Coast of Somalia.

When it comes to piracy, states whose sophisticated navies patrol the Indian Ocean seem stuck between not wanting to deal with Somalia itself and not wanting to prosecute pirates domestically. The international legal regime on piracy offers a definition, the exceptional authority to stop and seize vessels on the high seas, and provides for universal jurisdiction, i.e. the authority for any state to prosecute acts of piracy.

Yet, states are not obligated to prosecute and states mostly decline to do so for various reasons. In 2009, as the number of piracy incidents continued to rise, international efforts focused first on domestic prosecutions by all states and secondly on prosecution by states in the region resulting in controversial transfer agreements between most prominently the EU and Kenya (and later the Seychelles).

In time, the capacity Kenya to absorb and prosecute transferred pirates came under severe strain, however. The Netherlands, Russia and Germany therefore argued in favour of an international mechanism to prosecute pirates, based on the existing legal regime.


Want to read more?

If you subscribe to a free membership, you can read this article and explore our full archive, dating back to 1997.

Subscribe now

Related articles

21 December 2011 by Thijs Bouwknegt

Being the ICC's Chief Prosecutor is a delicate and politically sensitivejob.ForLuisMorenoOcampo it has been "the best job in the world." Fatou Bensouda will be taking over his office in June. She inhe

07 December 2011 by Thijs Bouwknegt

December 7, 2011 Ivory Coast is the latest playgroundoftheInternationalCriminal Court. This week the courtroom in The Hague became its theatre of justice. Chief Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo proudly p

07 December 2011 by Richard Walker

Four Congolese witnesses testifying at the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, find themselves caught in a legal wrangle, which could at once set a legal precedent and make them the last

07 December 2011 by Lindy Janssen

Brazil is booming. The economy is expanding and the country is getting ready to host the Football World Cup in 2014 and the Olympics in 2016. But the Latin American giant has not even begun dealing wi

07 December 2011 by Radosa Milutinovic

The primary purpose of the retrial of Ramush Haradinaj, as proclaimed by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in its appeal judgement in July, should have been to hear testimonies of two "key" witnesses who proved unwilling to testify in the original trial in 2007. Almost four months into the retrial which started in mid-August, its stated aim has not yet been achieved.